Statistics
| Appearances for Grange | Name | Grange Career |
| 407 | WFM Whitelaw | 1928-73 |
| 394 | CJ Warner | 1971-93 |
| 385 | AGG Asher | 1882-1915 |
| 385 | GB Green | 1896-1925 |
| 376 | DIAS Craig | 1955-76 |
| 354 | CS Scobie | 1927-54 |
| 352 | SJ Davidson | 1996-2022 |
| 339 | BGW Atkinson | 1926-55 |
| 316 | LM Balfour-Melville | 1870-1926 |
| 315 | F Ingham | 1967-82 |
| 297 | IR Beven (club professional) | 1986-98 |
| 289 | JD Matthews | 1948-76 |
| 278 | FA Jones | 1953-80 |
| 278 | GC Turner | 1975-90 |
| 273 | CW Mullins | 1985-99 |
| 268 | AW Duncan | 1901-31 |
| 267 | CJL Boyd | 1889-1913 |
| 266 | G Addison Smith | 1892-1919 |
| 264 | F Hunter | 1876-1915 |
| 256 | RH Johnston | 1885-1907 |
| 256 | DL Addison Smith | 1892-1910 |
| 256 | EGR Thornton | 1970-80 |
| 254 | DS Oates | 1979-99 |
| 244 | CKJ Kirsop | 1967-79 |
| 236 | ES Balfour-Melville | 1877-1909 |
| 234 | RC Smith | 1994-2005 |
| 233 | SJS Smith | 1999-2014 |
| 232 | JO Grieve | 1927-48 |
| 229 | JW Keene (club professional) | 1907-23 |
| 225 | NFI McCallum | 2005-18 |
| 219 | G Goudie | 2013-23 |
| 214 | AG Davies | 1988-97 |
| 213 | HJ Preston (club professional) | 1920-28 |
| 211 | BL Peel | 1904-24 |
| 204 | R Flannigan | 2012-23 |
| 203 | AR Wilson | 2000-10 |
| 200 | GC Holmes | 1994-2013 |
ES & LM Balfour changed their surnames to Balfour-Melville in 1893, when their father succeeded to the estate of Mount Melville, near St. Andrews, Fife.